Legal Updates
The latest costs case law and practice developments affecting legal costs in England and Wales.
Latest costs case notes
Case analysis from Mackenzie Costs, the regulated costs practice behind this platform.
Rosgonki v Formula One: Security for Costs Where Claim and Counterclaim Overlap [2026] EWHC 2899 (Comm)
In Rosgonki v Formula One [2026] EWHC 2899 (Comm) Andrew Baker J ordered security for costs against a Russian claimant, limited to the issues arising only on its claim and not on the defendant's larger counterclaim. He restated the Crabtree principle and declined to follow two recent decisions on Dumrul undertakings.
Read the full noteAlphier Capital v Blyvoor Gold: When Is a Success Fee Earned Where Two Advisers Share the Work? [2026] EWCA Civ 1432
In Alphier Capital v Blyvoor Gold [2026] EWCA Civ 1432 the Court of Appeal upheld a US$2.25 million success fee for a finance broker that had not introduced the investor. Where two brokers worked jointly, the contract required only that the broker's own work had a real world effect on obtaining the funding.
Read the full noteGopalakrishnan v Home Office: Fundamental Dishonesty After Discontinuance Lifts QOCS on a £7 Million Claim [2026] EWHC 2856 (KB)
In Gopalakrishnan v Home Office [2026] EWHC 2856 (KB) Mansfield J found a personal injury claim of over £7 million fundamentally dishonest after the claimant discontinued, and gave permission under CPR 44.16(1) to enforce the costs of the whole claim in full. The issue was tried under PD 44 paragraph 12.4(c).
Read the full noteCorporation Leasing v Irwin Mitchell: Settlement Advice, Reliance on Counsel and Fees Claimed as Damages [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB)
In Corporation Leasing & Finance Limited v Irwin Mitchell LLP [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB), Mansfield J dismissed a professional negligence claim brought by a commercial lender against the solicitors who had settled two sets of proceedings on its behalf. The High Court held that the solicitors were not negligent in advising settlement, were entitled to rely on counsel's advice, and caused no loss. The judgment applies the Langsam v Beachcrofts line of authority on settlement advice and the Perry v Rale
Read the full noteParsons v Convatec: Paying Party's Means Cap a Costs Budget Under Section 106 [2026] EWCA Civ 1357
In Parsons v Convatec Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1357, the Court of Appeal held that section 106(1) of the Patents Act 1977 applies when the court approves costs budgets in an employee inventor compensation claim. The financial position of the parties is therefore a relevant circumstance at costs management, not only when costs are finally awarded. Setting aside the decision below, the court limited the employer's approved budget for future costs to £4 million, against roughly £6.5 million approved by
Read the full noteRussian Federation v Hulley: Security for Costs of an Appeal and a £2m Brief Fee Cut Down [2026] EWCA Civ 1353
In The Russian Federation v Hulley Enterprises Limited & Ors [2026] EWCA Civ 1353, the Court of Appeal ordered the Russian Federation to provide £975,000 as security for the costs of its appeal in the Yukos award enforcement proceedings, by 4pm on 1 March 2027, failing which the appeal will stand struck out. The court held that an application for security under CPR 25.29 is not an application for a condition under CPR 52.18(1)(c), so the bar in CPR 52.18(3) does not apply. It found a real risk o
Read the full noteMariana v BHP: Pre-Judgment Interest on Costs for CFA-Funded Claimants [2026] EWCA Civ 1319
In Município de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1319, the Court of Appeal held that claimants funded by conditional fee agreements can be awarded pre judgment interest on costs under CPR 44.2(6)(g), even though they have paid nothing towards those costs. The Master of the Rolls held that the power compensates a receiving party either for being kept out of its money or for being liable to compensate someone else for providing legal services on credit. A contingent liability to pay a
Read the full noteHenderson v Ministry of Defence: Without Prejudice Costs Breakdowns Stay Privileged [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO)
In Henderson v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO), Costs Judge Whalan held that the Ministry of Defence could not rely at detailed assessment on without prejudice costs breakdowns that the claimants' solicitors had served to obtain payments on account. The breakdowns claimed more than the later certified bills, but the judge found that they recorded costs the claimants had actually incurred. A gap between a receiving party's without prejudice figure and its open bill was not unambiguous
Read the full noteCosts of a Preliminary Issue Trial in Libel: Paul Little Construction v Byrne and Sharif v Associated Newspapers
Costs in the case is the usual order after a trial of preliminary issues on meaning in a libel claim. Eardley J applied Sharif v Associated Newspapers in Paul Little Construction v Byrne [2026] EWHC 2577 (KB): a party seeking a different order must show an unreasonable stance that caused unnecessary costs.
Read the full note